I will give you 50% of ALL of my PROFITS if you teach me how to make profits? - Mastro's Steakhouse New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Mastro's Steakhouse New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Mastro's Steakhouse New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
Mastro's Steakhouse New York Reviews from The Last Year
Celebrated my birthday here and had a lovely time.
We sat downstairs and had a great server. The drinks were great, we had a few lemon drops, a few shots and a strawberry something lol. Food was great as well, we had lobster tails, the porter house, and tuna. The sides were mash potatoes, spinach and the birthday cake was delicious as well. The vibe was nice, very relaxed and low lit, game was on and music was also playing.
Good food
Awesome food , great service. The drinks are very flavorful. I would highly recommend. Exquisite steaks. Make a reservation
Great food, friendly service and very clean restaurant!
Great food, friendly service and very clean restaurant! Only complaint is that the music is SO loud, we couldn't have nice dinner conversation. We ordered the bone in ribeye and the branzino, both of which were AMAZING.
Could be cleaner.
Bugs everywhere. A huge mother roach was on my table as I paid my tab. Food is good, chefs are amazing. Place is dirty!!!
Do your homework, go elsewhere
Service: was good, our waitress was polite and knowledgeable. Came to the table often and when something needed to be replaced it was quickly Food: I had an overpriced 22 oz Ribeye with the bone. When it arrived, it looked like a 12 oz shriveled up worn out piece of meat. For the cost, way too much fat. The sides were decent, had garlic potatoes, and sautéed Spinach. Dress Code: From their website, they want you to believe that they have a dress code. While I was there, everything they say they would not tolerate, they allowed in. That might sound snobbish, but when you take the time to dress according to their requirements and it is 95 degrees outside, I would have loved to have worn shorts as the other patrons. The stars they get for my review are strictly for the service. I will not go to this place again.
I felt excluded from the crowd.
I was frustrated and it felt like I had to yell to get any service. The first waiter didn't mention the daily specials or ask if I wanted to eat or just have a drink. I have to ask a second waiter about the specials. The crab cake was dry and lacked flavor... it needed the lemon sauce to have flavor. To add to the disappointment, the food wasn't brought out evenly. Additionally, if you're not pale-skinned or without a second person with you, they dismiss you. I don't plan on returning.
The best thing was the lemon butter cake.
The atmosphere was loud and the service was not attentive.
It's a bit hard to differentiate steakhouses, but I really
It's a bit hard to differentiate steakhouses, but I really appreciate Mastro's consistency. My steaks and dishes are always cooked to perfection, and I always feel as though my waiters are very friendly. They definitely live up to their reputation! Overall really enjoyable.
We went here for my sons birthday.
The atmosphere is great, exactly what you would expect for a steakhouse. We started out with a few drinks from the bar and everyone enjoyed their drink. I will say that $25 for the whiskey sour with Angels Envy is expensive! We sat down and ordered bone marrow, tuna tartar for appetizers both were excellent. For dinner everyone ordered steak. Four of us ordered the NY strip and one ordered a ribeye. We all shared garlic mashed potatoes and asparagus as side dishes. The steaks were all cooked perfectly and everyone thought their steak was very good, my son rated his ribeye as 9 out of 10. My opinion was different. My first bite of the steak was a hard piece of grizzle that I couldn't eat. Then I tried the steak and it had a different taste that's what I'm used to. I've been to at least 25 high end steak houses and know what I like in a steak. It should be served with salt pepper only. Also keep in mind the steaks we ordered are not dry aged. When I took my second bite, it tasted a little sweet and something was off for me on the flavor. I tried another bite and just couldn't eat it. It was cooked medium rare just as I requested too. We told the waiter and within a few minutes the manager came over and explained that all their steaks are made with a Cajun rub. And that explained it. He offered to cook me another steak with just salt and pepper but at this point everyone was at least half way done eating and I thought it would take too long so I just asked to have it taken off the bill. I feel that we should have been told how the steaks were prepared when we were ordering. We had a few desserts too which we all loved. So for me, I don't think in would go back and get a steak. It's unfortunate. I was really looking forward to having a great steak. Overall everything was great except for the steak.
Swanky steakhouse with great service and food.
We did a midweek early evening reservation. It has a very moody romantic setting but our table was adjacent the bar and the music was WAY too loud. I felt like I was having to shout just to talk to my spouse. I was hoping for a more intimate birthday dinner date location. This felt more like a party steakhouse. That being said, the food was delicious. Ours steaks were cooked perfectly and everything was fresh. We each had a drink while waiting for our dinner and they were equally as good! They did bring my husband out a piece of complimentary cheesecake for his birthday, not complaining but I wish they would have mentioned they were doing this as we had fully intended to order the butter cake as we had heard so much about it and essentially in the end wasted the cheesecake as we were on our way to a broadway show and did not want to carry it. The prices are in line with what you would expect to pay for a high end steakhouse.
First time here.
On our way to a show at radio City. The service is phenomenal. Even the bathroom attendant Wanda is wonderful. Food is amazing. I cant wait to go back. Highly recommend the ribeye. It was like butter. Opened with wedge salad and shrimp cocktail. Cant say enough. My only negative comment is that because I was going to a show I could not wrap up what was left and bring it home. Lol. Will definitely be back!
I was there for a business meeting, the service was
I was there for a business meeting, the service was wonderful, the waiter Bryce was very pleasant and my steak was delicious. I will be back for an evening show there !
Never Again
Very disappointed, wanted to celebrate my grandson's birthday. Ordered the tomahawk steak. The steak was excessively fatty, parts you could not eat. I complained to the Matre de and all he said is that he would tell the chef. It was a lot of money for some fat.
Mastro's steakhouse is a bi-level, high-end dining
Mastro's steakhouse is a bi-level, high-end dining establishment located on 52nd street and the Avenue of The Americas in NYC that offers an extraordinary luxurious experience with exceptional service and fine cuisine in its elegant atmosphere. The ambiance of fancy restaurants like Mastro's are often carefully designed to create an environment of elegance using elements such as decor, lighting, furnishings which provides clients with the feeling of exclusivity. I was there with my friend and everything was absolutely perfect. From the waitstaff to the food. We were extremely impressed and plan on returning.
Always memorable food and exceptional service at Mastro's.
Great for a date, birthday or anniversary dinner.
Had a great evening at Mastro's.
Ambiance was dark, loud steakhouse vibe. Wait staff Ronnie was spot on delivering a perfect birthday evening. Seafood tower was amazing as was the filet. We will gladly return next trip.
Great steaks great for people watching!!!z the steaks are
Great steaks great for people watching!!!z the steaks are great service is excellent. Make sure you have reservations on the weekend
Pricey but the most quality meal and service around.
My husband and I love coming here for celebratory dinners because the ambiance is perfect for us. They have live music at least on weekends and even the bar area offers a fancy dining experience but with a more casual feel. Go tos: The bone-in filet is their signature Crab cakes are full of crab meat French onion soup is superb Warm butter cake is decadent Schezuan green beans were fantastic!
I've been to this places a couple of times.
It's quite nice. Good steaks and fish. And we got a table immediately. So I satisfied overall. Nice old fashioned restaurant.
Happy 22nd Birthday Mesha .
This place is pricey but photo opportunity and you get alot portion wise. The server was friendly and excellent brought out every meal we ordered and even took selfies with us. It was packed but we felt like we were the only ones there was a live singer that filled the room with tunes and laughter. I definitely will be back with Birthday Girl we had a blast
Wonderful steakhouse located in Manhattan.
Food and drinks were special. Service was great. Strip steak was cooked superbly and is very memorable.
Food could have been better but not complaining because we
Food could have been better but not complaining because we came on a late Sunday evening, our server George made up for the food with exceptional service and we really appreciated that
Horrible service from the host
Horrible 😣 service I reserve on the app an they still call me to confirm my reservation didn’t tell me anything about the dress code I even came in early in person to drop a gift for when we arrive to give it to the birthday person an still didn’t advice me of the dress code we drive a hour to come eat here an still told the host is his birthday we drive a whole hour here an the host Still dismissed us… mad disrespectful.. specially from the host an we still ask to speak to a supervisor manager an she actually ask us concerning what an that they are too busy to speak to us
Food was great, ambiance was perfect for a birthday date
Food was great, ambiance was perfect for a birthday date night. Our server was amazing and very personable. Will return!
Bad Service & Bad Dress Code
I have been at Mastro's over a dozen times and even hosted several parties there. The night before I was there, and the Vice President of my company had dinner there and told me the service was horrible... I didnt think much of it but when I went there Sunday 2-4-2024 not only did we have 6:30 reservations and still waited an hour until finally 7:37 walking out but the staff acted like it was no big deal that we were waiting or leaving.... Also, we were dressed per the dress code and half the place looked like it was gang night out in NYC.... No way ever giving them business again!!!!!
Disappointing
When we got there they were rude from the start. It was mad busy, big parties going on. We were seated by the toilet in the down stairs area with a picture on the wall to look at. We had lobster and shrimp cocktail which was presented nicely and steak rib on bone and a petit filet 6oz, and it was petite! We were given the signature butter cake without asking which we assumed was complementary and when finished presented with the bill, again without asking or if we were finished, to find we had been charged for the butter cake! When we left we had to ask for door man to get our coats as the cloakroom lady had disappeared. Disappointing considering the price. There are far superior restaurants in NY
The best Steak ever
Wow, the best steak we have ever had, and we have been to some of the best restaurants in the world including steakhouses and other restaurants in Atlantis Dubai and Bellagio Las Vegas. Good food, outstanding service from staff. Located not far from 5th Avenue, so pleased we found it. Highly recommend a visit.
Good Times.Modern and Fun.
We had pre booked. Arrived early and sat at the bar and made to feel welcome. The live piano was great, made for a lively but easy night. The food was great! The NY Strip was tasty and prepared perfectly. The sides for 2 were enough for a family!! Would recommend this restaurant.
Night club not a restaurant.
Rude receptionist. Set up like a trashy club instead of a restaurant. I’m a regular in the restaurants in LA/OC. Completely different restaurant, completely different vibe. If you want a nice restaurant, don’t go here.
Terrible attitude!
Went to eat a good steak before a show and couldn’t even be seated. They had a terrible attitude and told my child that their “athletic wear” wasn’t up to the restaurants standards. Do yourself a favor and do not go to this tourist trap.
Hostess
Good evening, I went to Mastro’s tonight around 7pm for a night out in the town with my lover on 6th ave & we were super excited to eat there. However, that is not how the night ended. I am not too sure of the hostess name but she has semi short red curly hair. She was highly disrespectful in her delivery when speaking with us. We were dealing with a male hostess and she inserted herself in the conversation. Her immediate insert wasn’t pleasing, her demeanor wasn’t friendly and her tone was disrespectful. At one point she found herself going back and forth with me. I had to remind her I was the customer. But she continued to be rude and it resulted in me leaving out the restaurant.
Mastros did not disappoint!
We have been to several Mastros locations over the years and have always had a great meal. This time we were in NYC celebrating our 30th wedding anniversary. Food was fabulous. My husband had the bone in filet and I had the sea bass. Everything, including the sides of Brussel sprouts, garlic mashed and Mac and cheese were delicious! Yup, way too much food! Also started with mussels on the half shell. The only reason I did not give 5 stqrs is the waiter could have been more attentive which I have seen as a regular complaint at this location.
You can’t go wrong!
Mastro’s is pricey but fabulous! They do an excellent job. Just make sure you leave room for butter cake!
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Mastro's Steakhouse New York
Booked 3 times by Mastro's Steakhouse New York customers.
Ranked #6 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Booked 1 times by Mastro's Steakhouse New York customers.
Ranked #178 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Booked 1 times by Mastro's Steakhouse New York customers.
Ranked #9 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Booked 1 times by Mastro's Steakhouse New York customers.
Ranked #1 in New York's Best Restaurants.
I will give you 50% of ALL of my PROFITS if you teach me how to make profits?
By 👻 @HarmlessOven17, 04/26/2024 2:52 pm
|
If you teach me to make money I will in exchange give you 50% profits
4 Answers
4 Comments |
Don't like the Answer? Add another one. |
Answer from 🍑 @BraveCloth47 (04/26/2024 2:58 pm)
|
LOL. Thank you The New Yorker.
4 Comments
|
Comment |
By 🍕 @DemonstrativeRegret77 (04/26/2024 3:01 pm)
|
By 🍑 @BraveCloth47 (04/26/2024 3:08 pm)
|
By 🎱 @PerceptiveWash44 (04/27/2024 7:15 pm)
|
Something new on Appointment Trader is you can actually purchase training time to help you learn to be a better seller. You can check out my wall if interested in scheduling some training time.
@PerceptiveWash44
By 👻 @FatefulRelation46 (08/25/2024 10:03 pm)
|
Answer from 🥷🏻 @ColorfulRod45 (04/27/2024 8:53 am)
|
That's what AT sponsorships are for - and you are only paying 25% in the first year and then less in year two and three.
I beliebe @EternalAnt36 was sponsored by @PerceptiveWash44 and is now doing $25k/mo.
You can write on the top sellers profiles (type 'Top 10' in the searchbar) and then tap request sponsorship button after you found the guy or gal like to work with!
0 Comments
|
Comment |
Answer from 😎 @MaternalRecord73 (04/28/2024 2:30 am)
|
We will launch our training course soon, it will give you secrets on how to make $200k + a year.
With almost $400k in sales we would be happy to show you our tricks and welcome you in our team
0 Comments
|
Comment |
Answer from 👻 @FatefulRelation46 (08/25/2024 10:17 pm)
|
I WILL AS WELL
0 Comments
|
Comment |