New York Prime Atlanta Tripadvisor Reviews - New York Prime Atlanta - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at New York Prime Atlanta for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at New York Prime Atlanta from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
![Read Less Action Icon](/images/ios-arrow-up.png)
Atlanta's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of New York Prime Atlanta
New York Prime Atlanta Tripadvisor Reviews
Latest Reviews On Tripadvisor
20 Reviews
0 Replys |
Top tier steaks and cocktails+ lively setting + attentive service = Dinner perfection!
Our group of 8 had a reservation a few days before Christmas (busy!) . There is valet parking. We were seated on time and there was a full house. The atmosphere was classic steakhouse, yet unpretentious and had a fun energy with great music at a perfect volume. I have been here 2x before on dates and sat in a booth, they are lovely and I highly reccomend asking for a booth if at all possible. Our party of 8 had a table in the middle of a busy floor and it was still ok. Our order was taken promptly and great dinner and drink suggestions were offered from our server. We had oysters and the biggest shrimp cocktail and stone crabs Iโve ever seen for apps. Also served: warm fresh bread. In our group we had NY strips, salmon, Crabcakes, Ribeye, Filet- each dish came out the perfect temperature. The salads were split table side from our server (Jack) who also shook our cocktails and served them table side. The quality of the entire dinner was exceptional. We were full but decided on chocolate cake anyway and the serving was big enough for all 8 of us. Wow! Donโt hesitate to book your party, large or small at this Buckhead gem.
Be the first to ReplyRodney the GOAT excellent customer experience
Everything was exceptional and top notch. our waiter Rodney provided the best experience from food, drink and desert selection. the food was delicious and great atmosphere. please request Rodney as the GOAT!!
Be the first to ReplyReservation???
We had a 7:15 reservation and weโre not seated after an hour, so we left. (After no resolution from management) If you are understaffed then do not over book. Completely unprofessional. However we did walk over to Davioโs and their steak was AMAZING! Megan Johnson, please do better as a manager at New York Prime.
Be the first to ReplyExcellent
Always great food and service. Enjoyed wonderful service from Kelly and Cliff at the bar. Ordered the wedge salad and crab cakes. The crab cakes are the best in the city. Thanks for another great evening at NY Prime
Be the first to ReplyFriendly Staff and Delicious Food!
Went for a work event and Jordan was the reason I would come back over and over again! He exceeded expectations and provided outstanding service. Friendly, outgoing and kind too! Much more than I could have asked for attending the event. In addition to the amazing staff, the food and drinks were delicious. Not to mention with the beautiful weather, the patio is a great spot to decompress after work. I inquired about future events and the managers came right over to show me the space options. Canโt wait to work with them again soon - you should visit ASAP as you wonโt regret it.
Be the first to ReplyExceeding Expectations
Jable was the best waiter hands down!!! The food was amazing and cooked to perfection. We had the petite filet, lamb chops, crispy lobster and the Butter Cake and omg I was in heaven. We recently moved from Las Vegas and I have high steak standards and this restaurant and Jable exceeding my expectations! I have a new favorite restaurant and will return but, Iโm keeping my hopes up that I will have the best waiter in the building again. Thanks Jable!
Be the first to ReplyHumiliated and Embarrassed
As for the food the wedge salad was delicious as well as the crabmeat cocktail. The steaks were ok but nothing special. The sides were over priced and bland. Honestly we make better food at home. Read further for atmosphere Party of 4 seated outside on patio on rainy cold windy night. Wind gusts of over 40 mph compromised the safety of our party as well as other guests. Wind gusts also blew water under our table causing very uncomfortable wet seats. The large heaters swayed alarmingly close to tipping over several times. My coat as well as my husband's coat was damp and my boots are still drying out. We had called earlier in the week after looking at the forecast to change our table but was assured the patio would be an amazing dining experience. Little did we know it would be like this! Manager Geno Drew was made aware of the situation and offered no change of table. Then the crazy couple seated by us verbally attacked us shouting obscenities as they were leaving in hopes of provoking a physical altercation. I have no idea where that came from. The enraged man and his partner moved to our table reaching his body over me across the table threatening my husband's life. We were speechless and remained seated and calm throughout this entire incident. Three men came out to escort the couple from the patio (I guess) because they left. My husband and I had not spoken a word to this couple this entire night except when we were seated, we said excuse me as they had commandeered a seat from our table to stack the women's coat and purse. Incidentally this cccurred just as we received our entrees. Geno the GM only spoke to us after we requested his presence to our table and was condescending asking us to "enjoy our dinner". Seriously after that unprovoked attack and humiliation, that's his response. As we tried to finish our meal, I found myself utterly sick to my stomach and wanting to leave. We will never return and my advice for those wanting a truly delicious steak and fine dining experience: go to Rathbun's you will not be disappointed.
Be the first to ReplyCouple Dinner
Second time at a New York Prime and again the steaks are amazing! Overall wonderful experience, only 2 items of note that kept me from rating a 5/5. The table we were sat at was right beside an exterior door going out to a covered patio area. This was a revolving door and every time it would open our menus and napkins would blow off of our tables as the cold air blew in. Also, the broccolini had a very off almost burned plastic flavor. Overall, food was awesome and we enjoyed our night.
Be the first to ReplyGreat service, great steaks, loud atmosphere
Great service and delicious food. Shadrach was our server and he was excellent. Great wine by the glass and bottle menus. The Caesar salads were delicious and plentiful. Our filets were done perfectly (Medium + for a pink center). The southwestern cream style corn was a bit too spicy for us, and the grilled brussels sprouts couldโve used some balsamic glaze for flavoring. I wouldโve loved to have seen some Mac-n-cheese on the menu of sides. Really liked this place, but wouldโve preferred the music to be a little more Michael Bublรฉ and a little less loud 80โs, especially given the prices, but maybe thatโs not the intent of a NY steak house. Dinner for two with drinks, 2 sides and tip will run you close to $300.
Be the first to ReplyBest steakhouse I've been to ... in Atlanta
Actually I'll say it's my second-favorite ever ... and I do a lot of steakhouses. Some in Atlanta are pretty good (Flemings) some are OK (Mortons) and some not so good (I'm talking to you, Capital Grill Perimeter). Haven't tried the Palm yet, will report when I do. I started with my usual caesar salad. I like it with anchovies, and the waiter got tired of me saying "one more" and left the bowl with me (excellent, I love `em). Then a steak that I've not had before: a medium-rare "CENTER CUT FILET OF RIBEYE",which seems steak-ier than the usual filet while keeping the filet's great texture. I had it with bearnaise sauce, and it was all excellent and plentiful, plus it stayed hot. I was convinced to have a "CINNAMON WALNUT APPLE PIE" which I couldn't finish but wished that I could have, it was a dream. The barman had a good touch with a Manhattan (as in: not too sweet) and the martini was good. (I think it might have been Grey Goose rather than my preferred Ketel One, but I could be wrong, and in any case it would certainly be no harm done.) Oh, and a shout-out to the waiter as well. In case you're wondering: IMO the best steakhouse ever is Shula's in the Dolphin at WDW (Orlando). But this NYP is a close second, and I'll try it again to give it a chance to go to #1.
Be the first to ReplyOutstanding Dinner
We had an outstanding dinner with great food and service. Food was prepared as ordered. Drinks were good and the drink menu was extensive. They have a good wine list and prices are all over the place but you can find some values on their list. We will return in the future
Be the first to ReplyVery disappointed
6 of us went here last night 12/26 to have a really nice dinner, with a more upmarket restaurant to celebrate my sons 21st birthday. We had called ahead to see if they had outdoor seating and was told yes, they did. When we arrived we were taken to a makeshift 'patio' which was enclosed with large, clear tarp, and which a few 'Lawn Tables" (I swear - we were literally sitting amongst metal lawn chairs and tables. The little led lamps on the tables, would not stay lit. This was due, per our waiter, to the fact that none (on any table) had been charged. This 'patio' sat adjacent to the bar and loud, and I mean loud, music was playing such that we couldn't talk and hear each other. I am soooo disappointed I chose this place for dinner. It had great ratings and reviews, so I took it to be a good restaurant. Again, I am so disappointed, and angry due to what we paid. Others clearly had a better experience than we did, but what pathetic memories we have of this dinner. To the manager last night, I would be ashamed you would allow this to happen! I would love to know what he/she has to say. I don't think there is anything they can say. For ambiance, beautiful dinner, overall atmosphere and food, go somewhere like Bones, Capital Grill, or Frankie's in Sugarloaf. If only I had thought to take photos.
Be the first to ReplyI want to give a huge shout out to Cheesecake factory. It was my friends birthday and we initially were going to go to (
I would like to say my first time in Atlanta was amazing but it wasn't. New York Prime tarnished my whole trip. Coming from the north we hear stories about the racism down south but I didn't think I would see it on my first night at what I thought was a beautiful restaurant for my friends birthday.
We were a party of 11 going out for dinner for my friends birthday. Most of us were her family. Because we were a group of 11 they had to split us up and the last few family members hadn't arrived yet. As soon as our table was called and we sat down our other family members (4 black men) arrived and walked to our table to find out what was going on. Immediately an employee running up and told them they had to wait outside. When the men tried to explain that they were just trying to get information about the seating before they went back out the employee kept cutting them off and said they needed to go. My friends brother was holding a water in his hand that he planned on finishing while they waited and the employee tried to take it out if his hand and said you can't have that here. Her brother was so upset that employee reached at him and tried to take his water and asked him not to touch his stuff. At that point the employer told us that he was "not going to have this here" and told us we had to leave. We got up and left, my birthday friend was mortified that they treated her like this. We got up without a word and went to Cheesecake factory where they seated the birthday girl and her family and friends. Thanks to this restaurant, my beautiful black friend had to be asked to leave on her birthday at a dinner that she was looking forward and thanks to this restaurant, they allowed me to witness Immediately in Atlanta.
Top notch steak house. Great ambiance
What a great steakhouse. Our waiter, Lawrence, was excellent. We shared the center cut filet and had 1/2 portions of several sides. All the sides were delicious. Steak was charred rare and top notch. Service excellent. Wine choices were varied and also top notch. Ambiance great. A must in Atlanta.
Be the first to ReplyAmazing !!!
Steaks And Sides Are Incredible I Could Eat Here Every Weekend Service Is Great . Very Nice Buckhead Restaurant.
Be the first to ReplyWanted a steak got the Tomahawk! Thank you!
Went with friends to this very nice, high class steakhouse. We made reservations (highly recommended) for 8:15 earlier in the day and when we arrived we were offered the mod or or outdoor seating and of course we chose outdoor because it was a beautiful evening. However, the manager on duty recommended a very nice private booth instead because a big storm was rolling in and he didnโt want us to get soaked (thank you!). Our waitress was Jaya and she was wonderful, very nice and very engaging. We ordered the Tomahawk steak and shared it between myself and my wife and it was perfection.! ๐Thanks to everyone at the Steakhouse for our wonderful experience and look forward to returning.
Be the first to ReplyHigh end atmosphere and great price
Great choice. If you're looking for a great steak and exceptional service than this is the place to go. Nice bar too. Plenty of parking. Very interesting to get to. There's a street or ramp in the middle that will take you to the top. I recommend this place based on food and service.
Be the first to ReplyBest In Atlanta !!!
I Have Eaten At Most Of The Big Hitters In Atlanta And This Is Tied With 1 More As Being The Best I Love The Atmosphere And The Decor. Food And Service Is Incredible Will Be Back Very Soon.
Be the first to ReplyNot good in a city of good alternatives
Entry greeted ourselves to a hostess who was checking herself out in the mirror. That was an omen for how bad this place it. Waiter seemed nice enough and initial drinks came out timely. but that was the highlight of the night. Next was the very loud music from the seventies and early eighties โ great music just not at night and not at an upscale restaurant. Unfortunately, steaks came out same time after appetizer โ sent them back. Bisque soup was not good as the shellfish were over cooked and rubbery (not sure what they were and no one bothered to tell us). Steaks (second time) were ok but nothing to brag about. Steak house fries were awfulโ one big sponge of grease. We each ate one โ waiter asked about it and he said he would ask his manager to take them off the bill. They were not and waiter never mentioned it again. New York Cheesecake was just ok. Our check was there just as the coffee came. Felt hurried. 1 hour and fifteen minutes total time. Yes, we were hurried.
Be the first to ReplySteaks
Best steak and service I have ever had. Was a great experience. Very good staff friendly and very informative.
Be the first to Reply